93/100 vinous
"The 2004 La Conseillante took a little time to settle in the glass but eventually reveals pretty red brambly fruit mixed with wild hedgerow, broom and graphite. With aeration...
Etiketten leicht beschädigt / labels slightly damaged
92/100 PP
"Tasted at the château, the 2004 Montrose is a blend of 64% Cabernet Sauvignon, 32% Merlot, 3% Cabernet Franc and...
Etikett verschmutzt / soiled label
18/20 WW
"Mittleres Granat, feiner rubiner Rand aussen, also keine jener Farben die wie die andern mit tief violetten Schimmer bestückt ist....
18/20 WW
"Mittleres Granat, feiner rubiner Rand aussen, also keine jener Farben die wie die andern mit tief violetten Schimmer bestückt ist. Elegantes, nobles Bouquet, feine Zederntöne...
19/20 René Gabriel
"55 % Merlot, 42 % Cabernet Sauvignon, 3 % Cabernet Franc. Mitteldunkles Granat-Rubin. Nobles, verhaltenes Bouquet, Erdnoten, Trüffel, Tabak, Zedernholz und trockene Bac...
97/100 Wine Spectator
97/100 James Suckling
95/100 PP
"This strong series of 2004s continues with the gorgeous 2004 Ornellaia. A lively dark ruby, it is a vibrant e...
100/100 vinous.com
"The 2004 Masseto, one of my personal favorites, is positively stellar. I have always adored the 2004 for its silky tannins, stunning aromatic presence and total finesse,...